Donald Trump Promises to End Birthright Citizenship: Implications for Indian-Americans
President-elect Donald Trump has reignited the debate over birthright citizenship, calling the practice “ridiculous” and vowing to end it after his inauguration on January 20th. This fundamental right, enshrined in the 14th Amendment of the U.S. Constitution for over 150 years, grants citizenship to anyone born within the country’s borders, irrespective of their parents’ citizenship status.
“We’re going to have to get it changed,” Trump stated in a recent interview, suggesting a potential public referendum to tackle the issue. While this is not the first time Trump has raised the topic, significant progress on this agenda during his earlier presidency was absent.
Understanding Birthright Citizenship
The 14th Amendment unequivocally states, “All persons born or naturalised in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States.” Trump’s critics argue that any effort to eliminate this right would face insurmountable legal hurdles, as altering constitutional provisions is an elaborate and arduous process.
Experts have noted that such citizenship practices are not universal, and Trump’s stance reflects concerns over perceived abuses of the system. One contentious aspect Trump highlighted is “birth tourism,” where expectant mothers travel to the U.S. solely to secure citizenship for their offspring.
Potential Fallout
Should this proposal succeed, its impact would be widespread, including the Indian-American community. According to Pew Research’s 2022 analysis of the U.S. Census, approximately 4.8 million Indian-Americans reside in the United States. Of these, 34% – about 1.6 million individuals – were born in the country and currently hold citizenship under existing laws. Revoking birthright citizenship could jeopardize their status, leading to significant uncertainty.
Critics argue that ending birthright citizenship would create administrative chaos. A 2011 American Immigration Council factsheet warned that American parents might struggle to prove their children’s citizenship without birthright guarantees. Birth certificates, currently used as primary evidence of citizenship, could lose their validity, affecting millions of Americans.
Trump’s assertion that families would need to be deported “together” could also lead to the expulsion of legal citizens, raising ethical and logistical concerns.
Opposition
Despite Trump’s bold claims, skepticism remains about the feasibility of his proposal. Alex Nowrasteh, vice president at the pro-immigration Cato Institute, dismissed Trump’s statements as recurring rhetoric. “He didn’t do anything to further this agenda when he was president before,” Nowrasteh remarked.
As the debate unfolds, Trump’s proposal has reignited discussions on the balance between immigration control and constitutional rights. The legal, social, and ethical ramifications of such a move promise to be a contentious issue in the months ahead.
See Also:
Pushpa 2 Creates Box Office History
Ousted Syrian President Assad Granted Asylum in Russia
Bank Manager Assaulted Over Fixed Deposit Tax Deduction
Delhi Influencer’s Bizarre Green Chilli Lip Plumping Hack
——————————————————————————-
It would mean the world to us if you follow us on Twitter, Instagram and Facebook. At Newscazt, we strive to bring you the latest news and stories from India, World, Business, Sports, Entertainment and more. Our team of experienced journalists and writers are committed to delivering accurate and unbiased news and analysis.
